Paper 6: 𝗖𝗼𝗺𝗽𝗲𝘁𝗶𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 & 𝗠𝗼𝗿𝗮𝗹 𝗕𝗲𝗵𝗮𝘃𝗶𝗼𝗿: 𝗠𝗲𝘁𝗮-𝗔𝗻𝗮𝗹𝘆𝘀𝗶𝘀 𝗼𝗳 𝟰𝟱 𝗖𝗿𝗼𝘄𝗱-𝗦𝗼𝘂𝗿𝗰𝗲𝗱 𝗘𝘅𝗽𝗲𝗿𝗶𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗮𝗹 𝗗𝗲𝘀𝗶𝗴𝗻𝘀 ⦿ Published: PNAS ⦿ Insight: crowd-sourcing experimental designs is the future of behavioral science
RT @BSE_Berlin: 🗞️Reading tip: 45 research teams, including BSE members @kai_barron, @tilmanfries & @LeventNeyse, explored the impact of co…
🗞️Reading tip: 45 research teams, including BSE members @kai_barron, @tilmanfries & @LeventNeyse, explored the impact of competition on moral behavior. They found a slight negative effect but emphasized the challenges of design heterogeneity. #EconTwit
ここ2回はPNASの論文をもとに論文の再現性まわりの議論をしました! もうプレレジは普通になっているんだなというのをひしひしと感じます。 https://t.co/HFmsRVAdJ4 https://t.co/ZArMdqnUzL
RT @RationalityCRC: Does #competition affect #moralbehavior? 45 teams, including our CRC members @kai_barron, @tilmanfries , & @LeventNey…
RT @RationalityCRC: Does #competition affect #moralbehavior? 45 teams, including our CRC members @kai_barron, @tilmanfries , & @LeventNey…
Does #competition affect #moralbehavior? 45 teams, including our CRC members @kai_barron, @tilmanfries , & @LeventNeyse, ran different experimental designs to address this question. Read more in @PNASNews: https://t.co/wwnCIgRAO4 @WZB_Berlin @bse_
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @chrhuber_: We ran 45 different (!) experimental designs with > 18,000 @Prolific participants to identify design heterogeneity in experi…
We ran 45 different (!) experimental designs with > 18,000 @Prolific participants to identify design heterogeneity in experimental results + we find an overall (small) adverse effect of competition on moral behavior! See here: https://t.co/B78gMko0uV
@ZaccagniSarah @ESA_Lyon_2023 Cool!! Gender effects were not the focus of the competitiveness studies included in👇🏻 but maybe it’s useful to your project in some other ways https://t.co/lAKa0xygxq
RT @Nonicoc: Competition and moral behavior: A meta-analysis of forty-five crowd-sourced experimental designs https://t.co/omKKBRBl3K
Competition and moral behavior: A meta-analysis of forty-five crowd-sourced experimental designs https://t.co/omKKBRBl3K
RT @Zberry37: New work out now in PNAS! We were 1 of 45 research teams who tested the effects of competition on moral behavior. Overall, we…
RT @eugen_dimant: 🥳 Fun fact: I previously had a paper studying this exact RQ - largely null results & journals weren’t interested. I the…
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @physorg_com: Examining morality and #competition in science @PNASNews https://t.co/QPTK9VuSzV https://t.co/6663PE1BWE
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @Zberry37: New work out now in PNAS! We were 1 of 45 research teams who tested the effects of competition on moral behavior. Overall, we…
New work out now in PNAS! We were 1 of 45 research teams who tested the effects of competition on moral behavior. Overall, we found a small negative effect of competition on moral behavior, but with sig. design heterogeneity. Paper and summary 👇 https://t
🥳 Fun fact: I previously had a paper studying this exact RQ - largely null results & journals weren’t interested. I then joined this massive effort with almost the same design. Null replicated for me. But now it’s out in @PNASNews. Science can be se
Competition and moral #behavior: A meta-analysis of forty-five crowd-sourced experimental designs @PNASNews https://t.co/B8C0NzuZfj
Competition and moral behavior: A meta-analysis of forty-five crowd-sourced experimental designs 😈"We find a small adverse effect of competition on moral behavior..." https://t.co/KCeyFGXHHQ @PNASNews https://t.co/BSgKL0KLvr
Does #competition make us less moral? New research says yes, but only a little bit @ConversationEDU @PNASNews https://t.co/W5rhNgWhRN https://t.co/NEm4yen8GG
Competition and moral behavior: A meta-analysis of forty-five crowd-sourced experimental designs | @PNASNews https://t.co/7qRqwLu1W7
I have never seen a study like this: 45 independent teams testing experimentally the same research question (does competition erode morality?) This isolates the effect of design heterogeneity, and provides an informative answer to a longstanding question h
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Does competition affect moral behaviour? Meta-analysis of 45 crowdsourced experimental designs @chrhuber_ et al finds a small, but significant adverse effect, but also substantial design heterogeneity: https://t.co/6U4IFr6oSO HT @andre_spicer https://t.co/
RT @andre_spicer: Does competition make us less moral? This interesting study crowd-sourced 45 very different experimental designs to test…
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @physorg_com: Examining morality and #competition in science @PNASNews https://t.co/QPTK9VuSzV https://t.co/6663PE1BWE
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Happy to see this published and to be part of this! Thanks to everyone who contributed to this interesting research approach!
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @k_ioannidis_: A great collection of experiments reminding us that extrapolating from a single design to understanding how abstract conc…
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @andre_spicer: Does competition make us less moral? This interesting study crowd-sourced 45 very different experimental designs to test…
Does competition make us less moral? This interesting study crowd-sourced 45 very different experimental designs to test the theory. It found competition had a small negative effect on morality. Some of my colleagues @BayesBSchool are co-authors https:/
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @eugen_dimant: 🥁Finally out in @PNASNews🥁 Congrats to my fellow collaborators 🍾 Link: https://t.co/UhqgXhBKZ8 https://t.co/DAk1MgMZUa
A great collection of experiments reminding us that extrapolating from a single design to understanding how abstract concepts like morality and competition are related is risky as there are so many different ways to operationalize them (well 45 in this pap
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
A very interesting approach !
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @rimamrahal: Excited to see this paper out! 45 research teams designed an experiment each to test if competition affects moral behavior.…
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @rimamrahal: Excited to see this paper out! 45 research teams designed an experiment each to test if competition affects moral behavior.…
Excited to see this paper out! 45 research teams designed an experiment each to test if competition affects moral behavior. In our design, we found no evidence for an effect. #manydesigns
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @shafenbraedl: 🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Comp…
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
ME: Happy to be an AUTHOR in The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 🧐 NARRATOR: Author 33. Benefitting from an alphabetically-early surname. In fact, his eligibility was based on a random process- ME: [Sitting by the phone, anxiously awaiting
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Detailed thread on the results below. Congratulations and a big thank you to the coordinators and all other collaborators! 🎉🥂👏 https://t.co/YfU4r0uqKW
🚨New paper 🚨in @PNASNews, excited to have contributed one experimental design to this mega project on the effect of #Competition on #MoralBehavior https://t.co/I6sTHWlSq0 https://t.co/aLVZXJmIGM
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Examining morality and #competition in science @PNASNews https://t.co/QPTK9VuSzV https://t.co/6663PE1BWE
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
It's a great feeling to be part of a project where half of the field is my co-author. 😌😅 Kudos to the organizers who allowed us to be part of the team.
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
2/2 נמצא שלהתנהגות תחרותית יש קשר שלילי - קטן - להתנהגות לא מוסרית. זה המחקר: https://t.co/MhaIDYRdck
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Does competition affect moral behavior? Interesting insight from this meta-anlysis https://t.co/CeNpaWGRN6
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Hur konkurrens påverkar moraliskt beteende har dryftats länge och olika studier visar det ena eller andra. Denna imponerande studie gav 45 forskarlag i uppdrag att efter eget huvud designa experiment för att undersöka frågan. Svaret är att forskningsdesign
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Competition and moral behavior: A meta-analysis of forty-five crowd-sourced experimental designs https://t.co/omKKBRBl3K
@uniinnsbruck @econlab @flxhlzmstr Gefördert u.a. vom @FWF_at und #openaccess https://t.co/7o5467ViP5
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
Interesting way of scaling research through crowd source approach.
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @eugen_dimant: 🥁Finally out in @PNASNews🥁 Congrats to my fellow collaborators 🍾 Link: https://t.co/UhqgXhBKZ8 https://t.co/DAk1MgMZUa
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @eugen_dimant: 🥁Finally out in @PNASNews🥁 Congrats to my fellow collaborators 🍾 Link: https://t.co/UhqgXhBKZ8 https://t.co/DAk1MgMZUa
Excited to have been one of the research teams in this mega-study on #competition and #ethics , published in @PNASNews !
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)
RT @flxhlzmstr: 📢Glad to see our #manydesigns team science study online at @PNASNews. https://t.co/WF6VTmimCD A thread. 👇 (1/n)